Rate & Predict American Idol

I just re-listened to his performance, and I thought Scott was off-pitch for a lot of the song.  Now, I’m not saying he sang poorly, but on second listen, I think it’s clear that Ju’Not Joyner was the 2nd best male performance of the night, and deserved one of the spots in the Top 12.  At the very least, Ju’Not deserved a wild card spot over any one of the 4 female wild-cards.